Top Loyalty Program Design Mistakes and How Smart Brands Will Avoid Them in 2025

Loyalty is no longer about points, discounts, and mobile apps. In 2025, the real test of a loyalty program is simple. 

• Does it increase revenue? 
• Does it improve customer retention and lifetime value? 
• And does it do this without becoming an unnecessary cost to the business?

Most loyalty programs fail not because customers are uninterested, but because businesses design them incorrectly. The same mistakes appear repeatedly. The good news is that these mistakes are preventable when loyalty is treated as a long-term product and not as a short-lived marketing exercise.

‍

1. Treating Loyalty as a Campaign Instead of a Product

Many loyalty programs launch with excitement and decline into inactivity after a few months. Once the campaign ends, no one owns it, no upgrades take place, and it eventually becomes a discount tool rather than a growth engine.

Case Study: Starbucks Rewards

Starbucks treats loyalty as a core digital product. The program has a dedicated product team, a feature roadmap, and regular improvements. Features such as gamified challenges, order-ahead convenience, and personalised drink suggestions were developed over time, not at launch.

As a result, loyalty members contribute more than 58 percent of Starbucks’ revenue in the United States as of Q4 2024.

What businesses should do:

• Assign a clear owner for the loyalty program with defined responsibilities and measurable goals.
  
  
• Maintain a 12 to 18 month roadmap for new features, experiments, and updates.
  
  
• Review the loyalty program in leadership meetings, just like any key business product.
  
  

‍

2. Making Earning and Redemption Complicated

A loyalty program fails the moment a customer cannot answer two basic questions:
What do I need to do to earn rewards?
What do I get in return?

Complex earning rules, hidden conditions, and long legal text reduce trust and engagement.

Case Study: Sephora Beauty Insider

Sephora uses a simple system. Every dollar spent earns one point. Points can be used for products, exclusive events, or limited-edition rewards. Because of this clarity, more than 80 percent of Sephora’s sales come from loyalty members.

What works better:

• Use a simple base rule, such as Rs 1 earns 1 point.
  
  
• Introduce excitement with temporary bonuses instead of permanently complicated rules.
  
  
• Explain earning and redemption visually inside the app or website instead of hiding it in terms and conditions.
  
  

‍

3. Rewarding Everyone the Same Way

Many businesses give rewards to all customers in the same manner, without understanding their actual value. This leads to high costs with little impact. Loyalty must be based on fairness, not sameness.

Case Study: Emirates Skywards

Emirates segments customers into four tiers. Each tier receives appropriate privileges. These range from bonus miles and priority boarding to lounge access and personal assistants. Platinum members generate three to four times more revenue per year compared to entry-level members.

How brands should structure rewards:

• Segment customers using spending, frequency, profitability, and influence.
  
  
• Offer tier-based benefits that recognise value, not just transactions.
  
  
• Work with finance to ensure reward cost is justified by the revenue or retention it creates.
  
  

‍

4. Ignoring Data, Testing, and Iteration

Launching a loyalty program and waiting for results is no longer acceptable. Strong programs are built through data, testing, and constant improvement.

Case Study: Amazon Prime

Amazon Prime began simply as a free shipping membership. Over time, Amazon observed buying behaviour, renewal patterns, and customer feedback. The company kept adding relevant benefits such as video streaming, music, groceries, and exclusive sales.

Today, Prime members spend nearly twice as much per year as non-members. Renewal rates exceed 90 percent in mature markets.

Metrics every loyalty leader should track:

• Activation rate: How many customers start using the program soon after joining.
  
  
• Time to first redemption: Faster redemption almost always leads to higher retention.
  
  
• Breakage and liability: Unused points are not profit; they are financial liabilities.
  
  
• A/B testing: Test different bonuses, tiers, voucher types, and offers.
  
  

‍

5. Underestimating Fulfilment and Post-Redemption Experience

Customers remember reward failures longer than reward successes. A delayed voucher, expired link, or out-of-stock gift can damage trust in the program.

Case Study: HDFC Bank PayZapp

HDFC Bank faced complaints regarding slow redemption and limited catalogue choices in its earlier loyalty system. After upgrading to a real-time, digital reward catalogue with automated fulfilment and better partnerships, redemption rates increased and customer satisfaction scores improved.

Operational priorities for loyalty success:

• Partner with a reliable reward provider that offers timely fulfilment and tracking.
  
  
• Monitor customer satisfaction for reward experience specifically, not only for banking or shopping services.
  
  
• Ensure backup suppliers are available to avoid stock shortages or delivery delays.
  
  

‍

What Loyalty Must Become in 2025

The future of loyalty is not transactional. It is behavioural and emotional. The most effective programs in 2025 will be:

• Strategically aligned with revenue, retention, and lifetime value.
  
  
• Product-driven, with long-term management instead of campaign-based thinking.
  
  
• Data-focused, where every reward is justified by measurable behaviour or growth.
  
  
• Operationally disciplined, with seamless redemption and dependable delivery.
  
  

‍

Final Thought

Loyalty is not built on discounts. It is built on discipline, relevance, and respect. A customer should not stay because it is expensive to leave. They should stay because they feel recognised, rewarded, and valued.

The brands that understand this will not compete on price. They will win on trust, habit, and emotional connection.

‍

Ready to Transform Your Loyalty Program?

If your loyalty program has become a cost centre rather than a growth engine, or if you're planning to launch one that actually drives measurable results, let's talk.

Get a free loyalty program audit where we'll review your current program and identify exactly where you're losing revenue, engagement, or customer trust.

Schedule Your Free Audit

‍

‍